
*Photo from Fragrantica.com
I’ll start by saying that Poison and Hypnotic Poison are both of the same breed: thick and spicy. They last forever in a solid, radiant mass, and neither contain any of that delicate note distinction found in lighter fragrances. I find both of them hard to review because they’re so heavy-handed: it’s as if each note was buried in a bowl of frumenty. Nevertheless, both are very good, and deserve the attention they get on every department store counter in America.
Poison
Poison, like Manuel Uribe, is famous for being big. And reaching the stature of either of these entities is a feat in itself. Perfume, however, needs further distinction to become a celebrity, and Poison has that too.
Tuberose is the featured flower here, and it comes with a big side of grape soda. The note is listed as plum, but I noticed something about actual plums: I can’t smell them. The juicy twilight scent of perfumery plum is most similar to how the fruit tastes. As for spices, Poison smells like it includes everything in your cabinet. Interestingly enough, I smell a big powdery anisic note, usually reserved for tamer florals, and that note isn’t drowned at all by the rest of them. There is also a wallop of vanilla and amber to make Poison even more intense. Dior’s helpfully descriptive fragrance section lists the notes as coriander (top), tuberose (heart) and opoponax (base).
I can see how Poison got its name. Yes, it is huge, but Giorgio and Guerlain Insolence are also contenders for that category. What Poison has over them is concentration. This fragrance just doesn’t quit. That single, sharp echo that lingers over everything it touches long past the drydown would definitely have the tenacity to poison someone if it were ingested in lethal form.
Perfumer: Edouard Flechier
Price Range: Moderate
Recommended Occasion: Dressy
Release Year: 1985
My Rating: 7

*photo from Perfume Diary Perfume Diary
Hypnotic Poison
Hypnotic Poison is less dark, but equally intense. And Hypnotic is a good surname for Poison’s sweet-talking sister. Here’s what Dior’s website tells us: “Four contrasting facets – intoxicating bitter almond and caraway spice, opulent Sambac jasmine, mysterious Jacarandra and sensuous vanilla and musk– make for a compelling, bewitching fragrance fusion. ”
Tuberose and jasmine are the two sexpot flowers in perfumery. Hypnotic Poison puts jasmine in the starring role beside a smooth almond that doesn’t seem at all bitter (it’s more like almond milk), with vanilla and musk. This is even harder to review than the original Poison, because the notes are almost completely stuck together within a sufficiently dark but shapeless and omnipotent glob, like a Rice Krispie with more intent.
But it still smells wonderful. It’s better than the original Poison, and can be worn at all times.
Perfumer: Annick Menardo
Price Range: Moderate
Recommended Occasion: Any
Release Year: 1998
My Rating: 7.5
Another way these fragrances remind me of poison is because of their marketing. They come in a bottle that looks like something Cleopatra would have poured snake oil in. Or a lamp that a genie can pop out of. It’s very fairy-tale like, and the scents themselves are very oriental. I can’t think of another fragrance in which the marketing fits the scent so well.