S’Mac: Sarita’s Macaroni and Cheese (New York City)

kac_111025_phude_smac_front_600 (from phude-nyc.com)

I’ve already extolled the virtues of New York City’s smash hit macaroni and cheese factory S’Mac in my post 11 Most Memorable Meals of My Life, but I don’t think once was enough.

S’Mac was opened in 2006 by wife-and-husband team Sarita and Caesar Ekya. The Ekyas had already had success with The Peanut Butter Co. and decided to expand their comfort food empire. S’Mac in the middle of the East Village and is perpetually filled with students. It has a very simple premise: claim the market by only serving European-themed macaroni and cheese dishes and glass bottled soda. You can also pick and choose your ingredients if you’d like. Your macaroni and cheese comes in these four ascending sizes: Nosh, Major Munch, Mongo, and Partay! I order Major Munch. It comes in the pan it was cooked in, and they’ll ask if you want breadcrumbs. Get them.

I’m the kind of person who sticks to what I like, so I can only remember having tried 2 of the dishes: Parisienne and La Mancha.

The Parisienne has brie, figs (figs!), roasted shiitake mushrooms, and rosemary. It was delightfully heavy on the gooey Brie, and the sweetness of the figs and the earthiness of the mushrooms counterbalanced it and each other. I could taste the hearty dose of rosemary too. La Mancha has manchego cheese, fennel, and onions. I like strong cheeses, so I didn’t like it as much. Other dishes include the Cajun, Cheeseburger, Alpine, Masala, and other combinations that other restaurants wouldn’t think of. I also recommend getting a mac-and-cheese with goat cheese, cheddar, broccoli, tomatoes, parsley, and garlic.

You can also order delivery or carryout, so S’Mac can replace Chipotle as your go-to lunch.

My Rating: 10
Recommended Dish: Parisienne
Atmosphere: Small, crowded, and the color of macaroni and cheese.
Price Range: $10-18 per person
Clientele: Hipsters


East Village
345 East 12th Street between 1st and 2nd Avenues
212-358-7912 or 212-358-7917

First Park
Kiosk at the corner of 1st Avenue and Houston street

Murray Hill
157 East 33rd Street between Lexington and 3rd avenues
212-683-3900 or 212-683-3915


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to S’Mac: Sarita’s Macaroni and Cheese (New York City)

  1. Steve says:

    You’re killing me with this post. I would kill for a big ole dish of Mac and Cheese right now!

  2. abby says:

    You are SO right about this place! I’ve been there and had the regular old American
    macaroni and cheese, and it was superb. The place was packed and conversations
    were about how yummy the dishes were, and what to order on repeated visits.
    Thanks for this – haven’t seen you give a 10 yet, but this is one of those. 🙂

  3. formaggio says:

    Agree. Have been to the one in the East Village. It’s especially cold today, so their food would work right now. Summer, too, though, because it’s not heavy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *